Roast duck with haggis stuffing
Roast duck with haggis stuffing is a traditional Scottish recipe, an ideal way to give your Sunday Roast or festive season meal a flash of tartan. It's served with a whisky cream sauce and a range of vegetables such as roast potatoes, carrots and whatever suits you. Here it's also served with roasted pumpkin and beetroot with garlic and toasted pumpkin seeds.

I often spend time in Scotland in the autumn. My partner and I share the same birthday and somehow we often end up celebrating it in Scotland with close friends. And, when we're there, I like to cook with the fantastic local produce, both traditional Scots recipes as well as trying out fusion ideas. On this occasion we decamped to the beautiful little port of Tobermory on the Isle of Mull. When I spotted this lovely bird while we killed a couple of hours in Oban waiting to take the ferry to the island, a very special and specific recipe came to mind. Irrational, maybe, but I believe that cooking it in these tranquil surrounds made it taste even better...
Le canard historique
This recipe for roast duck with haggis stuffing is attributed to the French chefs that Mary de Guise—the mother of Mary, Queen of Scots—brought with her to Edinburgh when she herself became Queen of Scots before her daughter. Contemporaneous and later sources tell how Mary de Guise, from one of France's most important noble houses, elevated dining at the Scottish court. While there is no doubt that she significantly raised the bar with her cadre of imported top French chefs, the notion that she single-handedly brought top French cooking to Scotland reflects how feared she was and how many people sought to flatter her, especially during the period that she ruled Scotland as regent on behalf of her daughter, Mary Stuart who became the Scottish monarch at only six days old after the untimely death of her father James V.
The truth is that the French influence in Scottish cooking goes back far further, a reflection of the Auld Alliance, the treaty of mutual protection between Scotland and France against their enemies—almost entirely meaning the English—dating back to the late 13th century. Intermarriage between Scottish and French aristocrats, French and Scottish nobles becoming courtiers at each other's courts, and a long tradition of Scots travelling to France to study, all meant ongoing cultural exchange for centuries. And cooking was part of that. Just one of those French influences, present in this recipe but also in many predating it, is the use of fruit in savoury dishes.
While the direction of influence is most often discussed in terms of the civilising influence of French cooking on rough-'n-ready Scottish fare, historic documents show that it was more of a two way street. What the Scots lacked in refined cooking techniques, they made up for in the quality of their abundant game, fish and seafood and their unique methods of preserving them such as salting and smoking. There are numerous remaining documents testifying to the appreciation of Scottish smoked mussels, salmon and eel sent as gifts to the French court and noble houses.
For example, in relation to the tale of this recipe attributed to one of Mary de Guise's master chefs (who is not named) an early 18th-century document thought to be written by an equally anonymous librarian to John Murray, 1st Duke of Atholl, tells of how the chef had bewailed a lack of proper French boudin noir to create this recipe for roast duck, a favourite of the queen. But, after he had had to make do with haggis, the chef concluded that haggis, with its use of oats and limited blood from the sheep, gave a better flavour than boudin noir with its overpowering pig's blood and pork fat.
It is, of course, a florid, unsubstantiated account written nearing two centuries later. And, the writer, a Scotsman, is clearly bristling with pride at the product of his hame being better suited than French boudin noir. Yet, it is also easy to see how this national pride has played a role in keeping alive this a dish you will find on tables that date back to the time it was apocryphally created for Mary de Guise, a recipe some historians believe was created by a master chef called Nicholas Boindreid (either the same master chef who served Mary de Guise or possibly the father) documented as later serving her daughter Mary Stuart, Queen of Scots when she returned to Scotland from France.
In the original recorded versions of this recipe, it is for roast duck, a favourite of Mary de Guise. However, down the centuries, it has turned into a recipe for a fruity haggis stuffing that is just as often used with grouse, pheasant or guinea fowl; basically any bird that is "gamey" enough to not be overpowered by the flavours in the stuffing.
Halloweeny
Because I was cooking this duck a couple of nights before Halloween—originally the ancient Celtic New Year celebration of Samhain—I was led as much by colour palette as anything else in pairing my vegetables. Of course there were roast potatoes—there would be riots without them—but I additionally opted for pumpkin, beetroot and heritage carrots.
Roast potatoes are commonly served with this dish, though those truly signalling their Scottishness usually opt for tatties 'n neeps. This duo of mashed potatoes and swede or turnips, mashed and served separately dressed in butter, is traditionally served with the haggis on Burns Night. Other less traditional versions include roasting the potatoes and swede together in a pan.
Other additional side vegetables include carrots, cabbage, winter greens—such as Green Scotch Kale or Winterbor Kale—and Brussels sprouts or even boiled seaweed dressed in butter. Basically the choice is yours (as long as you like butter) and you can make it as much or as little like a usual Sunday Roast as you like.
Take note:
This recipe is for 4 to 6 diners depending on your duck as much as on sides and appetite. You can easily add more or fewer side dishes (or, indeed an additional bird), but to some extent your duck will define how many it can feed.
Please note that in the images I am cooking it with a duck that would serve 4 people and side dishes are cooked in relevant quantities. However, I must apologise for the paucity of images on this one. I was cooking in an open plan kitchen and was too distracted by animated conversation to remember to take timely pictures.
3 top tips to get this recipe right: |
|
|
|
Shopping list
for the roast duck with haggis stuffing
A duck to feed 4 to 5 diners; cavity cleaned and any giblets removed (if present)
Approx. 150g haggis (approx. 2 slices of a medium haggis; see above for alternatives)
3 sticks of celery, sliced
2 echalion shallots (or 4 round shallots); peeled
2 thumb's lengths of root ginger; peeled
1 ripe pear; peeled; cored and cut into fairly large cubes
6 or 7 de-stoned prunes (either the "soft" kind or rehydrated); cut into slices
1 tspn dried sage (for the seasoning)
1 tspn dried thyme (for the seasoning)
1 tspn white pepper (for the seasoning)
1 tspn garlic powder (for the seasoning)
1 tspn smoked paprika (for the seasoning)
2 tspns rock salt (for the seasoning)
for the whisky cream sauce
1 tbspn of unsalted butter
2 to 3 tbspns roasting juices (from the duck roasting pan)
1 thumb's length fresh ginger; peeled and finely grated
120ml Scottish whisky
200ml double cream
2 tspns cornflour (only if needed)
White pepper and salt to taste
for the sautéd beetroot with pumpkin seeds
2 tbspns of unsalted butter
Approx. 400g fresh beetroot; peeled, boiled and cubed
3 cloves of garlic; finely chopped
3 tbspns toasted pumpkin seeds
Black pepper and salt to taste
NB: I'm not including the ingredient specifics or cooking method for the roast potatoes, steamed heritage variety carrots and roast pumpkin since I am pretty certain these are easy enough to do according to your own favourite method and/or you may wish to serve the meal with alternative vegetables. I'm including the beetroot because it's a dish less commonly known.
Side dishes
As mentioned, my choice of side vegetables here is led by keeping it to an autumnal palette. I'm roasting potatoes using my favourite method, steaming heritage carrots then dressing them in a little butter, and roasting slices of pumpkin in the same pan as the duck.
The final vegetable side is a dish of sautéd pre-boiled beetroot cooked on the stove top. But, of course, you can pair this duck with any number of side vegetables from Scottish tatties 'n neeps to Brussels sprouts or mashed celeriac.
For what it's worth, on this occasion, I served it with a starter of locally smoked mussels on a bed of little gem lettuce dressed with seaweed chutney and a pudding of my take on cranachan made with crowdie, cream, blueberries, poached in red wine and, obviously, lashings of whisky.
Cooking method

the roast duck with haggis stuffing
About an hour before you plan to roast the duck, remove it from the fridge, allowing it to return to ambient temperature. Stab the duck in multiple places on all sides with a skewer or sharp knife point. Using clean fingers, "pinch" the skin, pulling it away from the flesh all over. This will help the skin to crisp. Cover and put to one side
Next, make the seasoning. Crush the dried thyme and sage, garlic powder, white pepper, smoked paprika and rock salt using a pestle and mortar (or better still, in a spice grinder). Using cleaning fingers, rub in the seasoning on all outer surfaces of the duck and over all surfaces inside the cavity. Re-cover, and place to one side
Next, the stuffing. In a mini chopper, chop the shallots and ginger and then add the haggis (or the toasted oats and merguez meat if you don't have haggis) and chop it until you have a fairly rough, "crumbly" mixture. In a bowl, fold in the pieces of celery, pear and prunes. Season with salt and a little white pepper
Stuff the cavity rather tightly. Then plug the opening to ensure the stuffing doesn't leak during roasting. Here I am using the top of the tall pumpkin I will be roasting as a side vegetable. Traditionally it was done with a thick slice of large turnip (which would also be used as a side vegetable). But, you can also use half of a large onion
Place the bird, breast-side-down, onto a rack or silicon roasting block in a roasting pan. Cover loosely with kitchen foil and roast in an oven pre-heated to 180°C. Place a reasonably large dish with about 2cm of water in it beside or beneath the bird. This helps retain moisture
After 30min, remove the bird from the oven and turn over so that it is breast-side-up. Increase the temperature to 200°C and roast without the foil, taking out of the oven about every 20mins to baste with the fats and juices from the roasting pan. Ensure that you turn the bird over, roasting alternately on each side over the duration of the cooking. A received wisdom is that a duck takes 40mins per kg + 10 additional minutes to cook at this temperature. However, I suspect this received wisdom is based on fattier farmed ducks. If your duck is lean—such as this wild wee laddie—if will often cook faster. So, keep an eye on it. For example it cooked to perfection in just over 1.5 hours versus the 2 hours it should, theoretically, have taken for a bird of this weight.
If the skin seems to be burning, simply re-cover with the kitchen foil, only taking it off for the final 10mins or so to get the skin to optimum crispiness. Once the bird is cooked—use a meat thermometer or check that the juices run clear when piercing the thickest part of the meat—remove from the oven, cover with the foil and allow to rest for 10 to 15mins, which should be enough time to make the sauce
Take to table on a platter for carving—or carve and plate—and enjoy with the sauce and side vegetables
the whisky cream sauce
When your duck is cooked, melt the butter in a suitable saucepan on a medium heat. When it starts to bubble, add the fats and juices from the roasting pan. Add the grated ginger, and stir together until the butter and fats combine
Reduce the heat to low-medium and add half of the cream, stirring in, being careful that it does not boil—the odd bubble is okay. Pour in all of the whisky and stir continuously as you wait for it to thicken. If this seems to be taking overly long—it's all dependent on the level of fat in the duck—add the cornflour and stir in
As soon as the sauce shows signs of thickening, add the remainder of the cream and stir in. Stir continuously, stopping only to season with salt and white pepper. As soon as it has reached optimum consistency—it should not be cooked down until overly thick—pour through a sieve into a gravy boat and take to table while piping hot
the sautéd beetroot with toasted pumpkin seeds
I always cook this side before the whisky cream sauce because that needs to be taken to table piping hot. Melt the butter in a large frying pan on a low-medium heat. When it shows the first signs of bubbling, add the beetroot and stir in. Cook, stirring regularly, until the beetroot is hot
Add the garlic and stir in. Sauté the beetroot until the garlic is cooked, but not burned. Season with salt and pepper to taste
Add the toasted pumpkin seeds, and fold in, reducing the heat to very low. Since they are already toasted, you're merely trying to get them back to piping hot, not cook them
As soon as all the ingredients are piping hot, remove from the heat and cover to keep warm until plating or taking to table in a serving dish
Alternatives
This is one of those rare dishes where I cannot really offer a viable vegan version: it's a roast duck with haggis stuffing! And, even if heading in the nut roast direction, that, at best, would get it to lactovegetarian with a few tweaks. Nope, this is not a meal that would be on the menu if I am cooking for vegan or veggie friends.
The same could be said for pescatarian friends. This is a dish of specific ingredients and it is what it is.
Pairings
On this particular occasion, we were on a small island with fairly limited wine options—well, more so after the first couple of nights when we'd depleted what we'd brought with us. But, my partner Luc developed a liking for a decent South African chenin blanc stocked by the local supermarket. While it had never occurred to me before, actually chenin blanc, especially the ballsy kind with pepper undertones, is an excellent match for this dish.
More often I have deferred to familiarity and served this dish with a German Riesling Spätlese from the Mosel—modesty prevents me from saying which one— or a decent Pfalz Riesling such as Dr. Von Bassermann-Jordan Ancestrale or Müller-Catoir Bürgergarten Riesling Spätlese, both of which are excellent paired with duck.
However, emboldened by the chenin blanc surprise, I now suspect there are far more white wines out there that would work perfectly with this dish. And, no doubt reds too. Though, to date, my one foray into dipping my toes into a red with this dish, a Spätburgunder recommended by a fledgling sommelier that is supposedly great with duck, proved a complete non-event and I have remained wary ever since.




Comments